What is the problem of the anti-vaccination lunatics?
Brent council (among many other councils in England) had to start an awareness campaign to motivate parents to start vaccinating their children again! Thanks to some idiots who *still* promote the idea that vaccines cause autism (despite the mountains of evidence collected in recent years), measles have been on the rise again and people are now facing the consequences. Brent Council Measles

The anti-vaccination crowd is constantly moving the goalposts in order to cling to their favorite idea that somehow vaccines cause autism and other neurological disorders. In the beginning it was the mercury in vaccines (in the form of the preservative thimerosal). Then, when it became evident that this was not the case (partly because of the scientific studies showing not even a correlation, secondly because thimerosal had been removed from most vaccines yet autism still continued to rise), they switched to aluminium; the too many toxins in vaccines; and the overwhelming number of vaccines that overloads the “underdeveloped” immune system of infants. Of course they always fail to provide evidence for aluminium and metal-poisoning from vaccines; they never mention which toxins and why would they affect the immune system in such minute quantities; and they just conveniently bypass the studies showing the huge capacity of the “underdeveloped” immune system to tolerate and fight millions of pathogens of all kinds.

These people have managed to scare enough parents so that measles is now endemic again in the UK. Measles cases have been constantly rising in response to the constantly falling vaccination rates. There have even been deaths due to measles. Vaccines have been the victims of their own success: parents (and even physicians) have forgotten what measles looks like and what terrible results can have on their children.

The outcomes of this anti-vaccination campaign are obvious: more sick children, more deaths, less educated parents, more money spend on treatments and hospitalization, and now more money have to be spend in order to educate people on the very basics again! To raise awareness for diseases that should have been eradicated! To undo the damage done by the lunatics! To get their children vaccinated for crying out loud! The most basic and easiest preventative measure they can get!

A couple of weeks ago, I received a typically stupid comment in one of my posts from an anti-vaccinationist, which generated some heated discussion with a reader, Chuck. Chuck was repeating the same old, tired, and refuted arguments and logical fallacies in a dead-end discussion. Go read it and have some fun.

So my question is this: what is the problem of the anti-vaccination lunatics? Is it:
  1. an obvious incapacity to understand simple physiology?

  2. an obvious incapacity to accept solid scientific evidence against their beliefs?

  3. a dogma so hard embedded in their peanut-sized brains that is impossible to reason them out of it?

  4. a tremendous susceptibility to pretty much all of the cognitive biases and logical fallacies Carl Sagan could ever think of?

  5. all of the above?
I am waiting for your answers in the comments… [this is more like a rhetorical question really -as sciencebitches has also noted...]
6 Responses to this post
1. sciencebitches
I dont think anyone is going to vote. this is such an abvious no brainer really!
[...] READ THE REST OF THIS ENTRY AT “JOURNEY THROUG A BURNING MIND” Posted in Uncategorized. Tags: aluminum, anti vaccination, Antivaccination lunacy, autism, Autism Science, detox, detoxification, immune system, immunity, mercury, thimerosal, toxins, uk, vaccines. [...]
3. sanabituranima
The “vaccine nuts” as you call are doing horribkle, horrible damage to innocent children (and sometimes even killing them), but they need sympathy. A lot of them are parents of autistic kids who just can’t come to terms with their kids’ disabilities. They need help accepting reality, so they no longer need someone to blame.
http://parnassus.co.uk/?p=199
sanabituranima, I understand what you are saying and you are of course right: normal unlucky parents have my sympathy! They have simply been misled and manipulated for the agenda of some others.

As a whole they are of course not part of the group I call “anti-vax lunatics”. This group consists of those people that *actively* promote the already falsified idea that vaccines cause autism: some reporters, some researchers who are getting paid by “organizations” like Generation Rescue etc. and only some of the parents you mention, like Jenny McCarthy and Jim Carey, who have done so much damage with the publishing of McCarthy’s stupid book and other activities.

These are the lunatics and the very very dangerous people.
Sciencebitches made a fair point that unfortunately is a bit pointless to vote. Specially referring to what is the problem of the anti-vaccination lunatics. I believe there is no need to add why and how they come up with such nonsense, they never have good solid evidence to prove their theories or even considering ideas they are trying to promote. As the word, “lunatics” fairly describes their nature and mind.

Going back to our main hero Chuck the lad, we simply have seen the nonsense put out by the anti-vaccination advocates. Especially when we relate to health, we have noticed that the amount of information and sources Chuck was talking about, simply was misleading and did not prove any idea. On the Other Hand, Stavros and Sciencebitches were trying to bring information to light for him. I believe Chuck forgot to balance his reading before actually going ahead creating a massive anti vaccination debate.

In addition, we have noticed that anti vaccination crowd not just time to time lie about their sources, but as well as they assume that references they provide will never be checked out. Well once again they are wrong, at least some people can actually notice and prove their argument regards to white lies they spread.

I don’t know if you came across, but see http://www.quackwatch.org/ , worth to check regards to homeopathy, medical issues such as vaccinations, anti-vaccination movement etc etc
Smith thanks for the comment and link -it is good to promote Stephen Barrett’s site as indeed it is a great source of quackery debunking.

Quackwatch was one of the first sites I ended up reading when I first started researching pseudoscientific claims. Barrett himself has been frequently accussed by the quacks of being paid by the Big Pharma, of being too dogmatic and close-minded and other signature accussations of people that cannot support their opinions with evidence and thus resort to fallacies of all kinds.

Quackwatch is well worth exploring it.
Add a comment
Leave a comment
(Email required for authentication purposes only and will not be published. Please also note that if your comment contains links, profanity, or other sensitive content it might be held for moderation. In that case it will not appear until accepted by the administrator. Please do not post the same comment twice.)
Name *:

Email (not published) *:

URL:


Comment: (you may use HTML tags for styling)